Western Iowa Tech Community College

KDSN RADIO News

Thursday, August 1, 2024

Naig says lawmakers could add guardrails to pipeline law

Naig says lawmakers could add guardrails to pipeline law

Iowa Agriculture Secretary Mike Naig says he’s concerned about what state law says about how crop land and pastures are to be restored after a hazardous liquid pipeline is built.

“Should we look at that law? I think we can,” Naig said during a recent appearance on Iowa Press on Iowa PBS. “Eminent domain use should be rare. It should be used when there are significant property agreements in place.”

The legislature’s priority should be establishing “guardrails” and defining terms, according to Naig.

“I would be careful of going in and saying specifically: ‘This kind of project should or should not be allowed,'” Naig said. “Look at those broader principles. Does it have an overwhelming impact?…Is it used in cases where there’s voluntary agreement? What’s the right number for that?…Maybe some additional teeth in the restoration process to ensure that land is useful afterwards. I think those are things that are very logical to look at after we’ve gone through a process now.”

Naig has read through the Iowa Utilities Commission decision granting a construction permit to Summit Carbon Solutions. “Nobody likes eminent domain. Nobody, but Iowa law allows for it and Iowa law allows for it when it’s justified. How is it determined whether it’s justified? Utilities Board. Should we look at that law? I think we can,” Naig said. “Eminent domain use should be rare. Eminent domain should be used when significant voluntary agreements are in place.”

But any eminent domain changes would be for projects proposed in the future, not the Summit pipeline. Naig said there could be “an upside” for the ethanol industry and corn growers if the pipeline’s built.

“Whether you like it or not…there could be an expansion signal even sent to the ethanol industry as we look at now using ethanol to make sustainable aviation fuel. If you’re going to make sustainable aviation fuel, you’ve got to lower the carbon intensity of ethanol,” Naig said. “There are many ways to do that, but we should be looking at all the options there. So is there potential value in this? Yes.”

Naig expects lawsuits will be filed to challenge the state-issued construction permit for the pipeline and he said there may be other things lawmakers can learn through that process.

Full News Listings
Johnson Propane
Western Iowa Tech Community College
Western Iowa Networks, internet
712 Digital Group, KDSN Radio, Digital Marketing, Digital Advertising
Crawford County Memorial Hospital
Vision Care Clinic
Blackbird Bend Casino Onawa Iowa
Western Iowa Tech Community College Denison Campus
Manning Regional Healthcare Center
Western Iowa Networks, internet
712 Digital Group, KDSN Radio, Digital Marketing, Digital Advertising
Crawford County Memorial Hospital
Western Iowa Tech Community College Denison Campus
Manning Regional Healthcare Center